You’re rushing through the grocery store, picking up the final ingredients for a romantic dinner when you realize the one thing you’re missing — that perfect bottle of wine.
A bill before the Minnesota Legislature would allow adults to buy a bottle of wine and some steaks in the same store. If state grocers have their way, Minnesota would join 33 states that allow supermarkets to sell wine.
With the results of a November 2006 public opinion poll in hand, Minnesota grocers are hoping to update the state’s liquor laws and give customers greater convenience, choice and competition by selling wine with other dinner items.
“We want a fair chance as the markets in the other 33 states,” Econofoods store director Tim Stocker said.
Opponents of the bill, namely the liquor industry, municipal liquor stores and public safety advisers, state the competition will not only cut into profits and reduce city revenue, but also increase the availability and underage access to alcohol.
“I don’t think it belongs in a grocery store,” said Litchfield Liquors manager Angela Decker. “It belongs in a liquor store where you have to be 21, and we card everyone.”
Minnesota currently allows grocery stores and other non-liquor stores to sell only 3.2 beer and malt beverages. Grocery, convenience, drug or general merchandise stores cannot sell strong beer, wine or spirits for off-premises consumption.
If the bill is approved, grocery stores of at least 8,000 square feet could sell wine with an off-sale liquor license.
The Minnesota Grocers Association started a Wine With Dinner promotion campaign last fall. It points to the November public survey by Decision Resources Ltd. of Minneapolis that shows 68 percent of Minnesotans favor allowing grocery stores to sell wine.
A March 2006 report by the Office of the Legislative Auditor found that wine prices, adjusted for differences in taxes and insurance costs, are 5 to 7 percent higher in Minnesota compared to Wisconsin, where grocery stores can sell wine, beer and distilled spirits.
The report concluded that the state’s more restrictive retail laws are “probably responsible” for the higher wine prices because of a lack of competition among wine wholesalers. If Minnesota were to adopt less restrictive liquor laws like those in Wisconsin, Minnesota consumers could save about $100 million annually. Wine savings would be approximately $15 million.
“Removing state restrictions on competition in the liquor industry would lower prices and improve convenience, but some adverse impacts are also possible,” the report stated.
Those impacts could range from jeopardizing the existence of state municipal liquor stores and eliminating $16 million transferred to city budgets to an increase in alcohol abuse due to lower prices and increased availability, according to the report.
Read more from grocers and liquor store managers and see where local legislators stand on the issue in the March 29 Independent Review on newsstands today.

So what do you think? There...
Back to page topSo what do you think? There seems to be good reasoning to both sides of the debate, and I'm curious of what you think about this issue.
Are you in favor of allowing grocery stores to sell wine, or do you think it's better left to liquor stores?
yawn. as a former...
Back to page topyawn. as a former litchfield teenager who had open access to alcohol from older kids, who assumingly had open access from young adults (21+)... access to alcohol in litch was rarely an issue.
i now live in california, we have two aisles in the grocery dedicated to wine and spirits, another for beer. the selection is fabulous. i rarely consume alcohol but it is sure nice for dinner parties to make one less stop. i'm twenty-nine and am always carded in my grocery store, i love the compliment!
the avenue of sale doesn't prohibit the use by kids, or force responsible drinking. parents need to assume the responsibility that having teenagers requires.
I have lived in california...
Back to page topI have lived in california and arizona where the grocery stores have a full liquor selection, It's very convient to have a one stop shop to get everything. In Missouri even the walmarts have a full liquor selection.
I don't think it is that big of a deal if you can buy a bottle of vino along with your groceries.
In general, I'm in favor of...
Back to page topIn general, I'm in favor of breaking the monopoly. But I guess it would be unfortunate for small towns that rely on municipal liquor store sales to lose a lot of revenue. How much business would a place like Litchfield Liquors be projected to lose?
Also, a little competition could be a good thing. Litchfield Liquors would probably be able to beat a place like Wal-Mart any day on variety, not just of wine but hard liquor and beer as well.
And some people will probably never want to buy a bottle of chardonnay at the same place where they can get their oil changed. Just the principle of the thing.
Most people have the first...
Back to page topMost people have the first reaction to competition as a negative thing for a business. This is not always true, there are many times that competition will increase business. I believe that most people who have a favorite alcoholic beverage will go to the place they know they can get it(ex liqour store) rather than have to settle for the limited selection that the grocery store will offer. Perhaps this will even prompt the municipal liquor stores to get to know their customers wants and needs better, thus providing a better selection/service for their customers. Everyone wins in that situation.
Scott Hornemann is the Internet Advertising Representative for the independentreview.net, you can reach him at websales@independentreview.net
Kotter, you asked how much...
Back to page topKotter, you asked how much business Litchfield Liquors would lose if grocery stores are allowed to sell wine. In the full article in our print edition, store manager Angela Decker said it's hard to know, but she believes Litchfield Liquors would survive.
Currently, 15 percent of Litchfield Liquors' business comes from wine sales. If the bill passes Decker said it would change how she does business because grocery stores would likely stock the best selling wines. She anticipates she would have to specialize and carry more “boutique” brands of wine.
On the other hand, as a municipal liquor store, profits are used to fund the Litchfield Civic Arena. The city transfers $60,000 from the liquor store to the civic arena fund every year, according to Decker.
Alcohol access should be...
Back to page topAlcohol access should be forbidden for kids and teenagers, but still I see drunk teenagers on the streets, it's quite sad to see those kids at this level of degradation, they are very vulnerable and hard to recover.
California drug northern rehab
My wife and I are not big on...
Back to page topMy wife and I are not big on drinking. My wife likes to drink Arbor mist and the premade stuff like dacqaries. Niether of us have ever been impressed by the stuff wal mart carries but have by cub foods but certainly do not drive to go the store. The store in town has good stock, how ever if they want to compete they are going to have to change thier hours. They should be open till 7 or 9 on week days and 10 on weekends. and what is wrong with it being open on sunday? oh wait the churches would have a fit with that.
Hi, Most people have the...
Back to page topHi,
Most people have the first reaction to competition as a negative thing for a business. This is not always true, there are many times that competition will increase business.I loved reading this article and viewer's comments.
Tia,
california drug rehab